Started by arch warmonger, June 06, 2021, 06:01:24 PM
QuoteIt was supposed to be the celebration of a grand career, as the American Civil Liberties Union presented a prestigious award to the longtime lawyer David Goldberger. He had argued one of its most famous cases, defending the free speech rights of Nazis in the 1970s to march in Skokie, Ill., home to many Holocaust survivors.Mr. Goldberger, now 79, adored the A.C.L.U. But at his celebratory luncheon in 2017, he listened to one speaker after another and felt a growing unease.A law professor argued that the free speech rights of the far right were not worthy of defense by the A.C.L.U. and that Black people experienced offensive speech far more viscerally than white allies. In the hallway outside, an A.C.L.U. official argued it was perfectly legitimate for his lawyers to decline to defend hate speech.Mr. Goldberger, a Jew who defended the free speech of those whose views he found repugnant, felt profoundly discouraged.â€œI got the sense it was more important for A.C.L.U. staff to identify with clients and progressive causes than to stand on principle,â€ he said in a recent interview. â€œLiberals are leaving the First Amendment behind.â€The A.C.L.U., Americaâ€™s high temple of free speech and civil liberties, has emerged as a muscular and richly funded progressive powerhouse in recent years, taking on the Trump administration in more than 400 lawsuits. But the organization finds itself riven with internal tensions over whether it has stepped away from a founding principle â€" unwavering devotion to the First Amendment.