Atheistforums.com

Extraordinary Claims => Religion General Discussion => Christianity => Topic started by: Iusedtobelievein on November 10, 2016, 07:09:09 PM

Title: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Iusedtobelievein on November 10, 2016, 07:09:09 PM
that soon we will all be nothing more than a rotting piece of flesh in a coffin?  Big change in belief.  I am having a hard time grasping the possibility that we will all be a rotting piece of meat in a coffin, nothing more, no afterlife for the people and animals I love (loved)...that I will one day no longer see the people and animals  I love (loved).  Mainly the God I believed in with all my heart and soul--or what I thought was a soul--is just magical thinking of the human brain.  How do I handle this...?...that we all are just a wink in a moment of time.  That you, me, them will one day be nothing more than a name...just a name in a census record...just a name.  And this will happen soon especially if one considers, really considers, that the earth is literally Billions of years...Billions of years old.  Billions.  And billions of humans have walked this earth...nothing special about you, about me, about the people I love (loved) including the children I have loved.That we are no more when we die...just creatures who die with nothing immortal about our souls...that souls don't exist.  So how does one go from believing in this to all this? Btw,  I have had too much wine to drink.  Because...because the thought that the mother I loved, that the animals I loved, end at the grave.  It's too much for this primitive animal brain to handle.

Help me please to handle this possibility sez the secular nun.  Big change...oh, yeah.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: aitm on November 10, 2016, 07:12:48 PM
If you cannot handle it, then by all means don't . Not that hard.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: doorknob on November 10, 2016, 07:18:35 PM
Maybe it's just me but, it's really not that hard. Death is a part of nature that every one must face head on. I can't tell you what happens after we die so why bank on the next life that may or may not exist? I have this life, the one I know exist and I have. I will live this one to  the fullest and when death comes to get me I'm prepared to take a big dirt nap.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Munch on November 10, 2016, 07:50:04 PM
I've not had a hard time of it adapting to this way of thinking, it just is.

I think of it like, stars turn into supernovas, and die, its matter blasting out across space and time, leaving a void at the end. There is no longer a star, just the husk of one. And if even stars and the planets surrounding them all go the same why, why bother getting upset about it, its just what it is.

Maybe try and just live each day and do the stuff you want with the people you love, and be happy to get to do it, not everyone even has that advantage, like those with mental deficiencies or genetic oddities that cause it. I was diagnosed with type 2 diabeties at age two, and if I was born 100 years before I'd be dead, so I'm just thankful i get to live, love, experience stuff, in the time I'm in. 
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Hijiri Byakuren on November 10, 2016, 08:41:30 PM
Don't make death into more than what it is. It's just a dreamless sleep, like before you were born. And as evidenced by accounts of near-death experiences, our brains have mechanisms to make death easier.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Hydra009 on November 10, 2016, 09:21:28 PM
Quote from: Iusedtobelievein on November 10, 2016, 07:09:09 PMSo, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering that soon we will all be nothing more than a rotting piece of flesh in a coffin?
I'd imagine it's roughly the same process that one goes through from believing anything outlandish and unrealistic to something much more realistic but also more uncomfortable.

Life sucks and believing differently doesn't change that fact.  Might as well face the music head on.  In fact, trying to sugarcoat it might inadvertently make things worse by introducing new anxieties (like hell).
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Absurd Atheist on November 10, 2016, 10:06:56 PM
Can you really imagine living forever? We put to much value in this life, I mean just look around at the chaos of this world. Donald fucking Trump is President, I'm not sure I'm happy to be alive right now. Honestly you'll be much more comfortable dead, where you won't have to worry about anything.

On that note, if you're really concerned you might as well try to be immortalized through history and make a great change in the world. Then at least you can die content. I'm sure that would make your loved ones proud.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Mike Cl on November 10, 2016, 10:16:19 PM
Quote from: Iusedtobelievein on November 10, 2016, 07:09:09 PM
that soon we will all be nothing more than a rotting piece of flesh in a coffin?  Big change in belief.  I am having a hard time grasping the possibility that we will all be a rotting piece of meat in a coffin, nothing more, no afterlife for the people and animals I love (loved)...that I will one day no longer see the people and animals  I love (loved).  Mainly the God I believed in with all my heart and soul--or what I thought was a soul--is just magical thinking of the human brain.  How do I handle this...?...that we all are just a wink in a moment of time.  That you, me, them will one day be nothing more than a name...just a name in a census record...just a name.  And this will happen soon especially if one considers, really considers, that the earth is literally Billions of years...Billions of years old.  Billions.  And billions of humans have walked this earth...nothing special about you, about me, about the people I love (loved) including the children I have loved.That we are no more when we die...just creatures who die with nothing immortal about our souls...that souls don't exist.  So how does one go from believing in this to all this? Btw,  I have had too much wine to drink.  Because...because the thought that the mother I loved, that the animals I loved, end at the grave.  It's too much for this primitive animal brain to handle.

Help me please to handle this possibility sez the secular nun.  Big change...oh, yeah.
Quite a culture shock for you apparently.  I can understand that.  To come from a sincere belief and to then realize (or be in the process of that realization) that a belief held with sincerity is just that; still a belief.  There are no facts of evidence to support said belief.  That is a big step to take.  But examine the things you are talking about.  Have you seen any evidence that supports immortality?  Or god's love for that matter.  Either is something is natural or it doesn't exist.  There is nothing I've seen that is super natural or beyond nature.  If you have to have a belief to support a belief, then it just really isn't anything other than a fantasy you want to be true.  I have lost many (people and animals) that I have loved.  And in my thoughts I still love them; and they live on in my head.  But one day I will become scattered atoms that will be used in the construction of something else.  And that's that.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Baruch on November 11, 2016, 12:08:03 AM
Quote from: doorknob on November 10, 2016, 07:18:35 PM
Maybe it's just me but, it's really not that hard. Death is a part of nature that every one must face head on. I can't tell you what happens after we die so why bank on the next life that may or may not exist? I have this life, the one I know exist and I have. I will live this one to  the fullest and when death comes to get me I'm prepared to take a big dirt nap.

This is actually Hindu (Shiva worship) and Buddhist ... it has to do with the meditation on the cremation ground (and the god Shiva, the uber-meditator, covering his face with human ashes).

Typically the Greco-Romans weren't so morbid.  The Judeo-Christians, a W Asian culture, brought in elements from pessimistic Egypt, Babylonia, Persia and India.

It was Buddha, contemplating the poor, the sick, the dead ... who renounced a perfectly good job as luxury prince.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Baruch on November 11, 2016, 12:16:17 AM
The unexamined life isn't worth living anyway .. and everyone has unexamined beliefs that they tie themselves into knots over.  Though I think the point of self examination, isn't nihilism, but clarity.

Most Western people believe in linear time, that we have one life only, and think that time passes them, not them passing time.  Many Eastern people believe in circular time, and that we live many lives.  Most people assume they are alive, that they are conscious, that they are good.  These are all unjustifiable assumptions.  Consider that you might in fact be dead, a zombie.  In Greco-Roman afterlife, most people ended up in Hades, as a kind of ghost, but some also believed in reincarnation after you had drunk from the river Lethe (forgetfulness).  This reappears as the Christian Purgatory and Hell.  Hell corresponding to the maximum security prison of Tartarus, where the elemental Titans are kept prisoner.  How different would you be if you were a Greco-Roman pagan?  What if Christianity is a form of Jewish-Buddhism, or Catholicism is Roman paganism continued by other means?

My ex was a nun ... so I understand that kind of crisis of faith (fairy tale).  In my case, as a Jewish Kabbalist, I am tolerated here as theist comic relief.  So this is a kind of Purgatory for me, but nicer than Hades.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Jack89 on November 11, 2016, 12:19:50 AM
Your mother does not end at the grave, and neither do you.  You suffer and enjoy the consequences of your actions, and here's the kicker, others are similarly affected.  Your mother lives on in you and everyone else she's made and influence on, and you'll do the same.  That moment of patience and kindness that your mother showed you, that you may not even remember, has in some small way made an influence on you and everyone you've come into contact with.  Similarly, those moments of selfishness and cruelty will have detrimental affects, far beyond what you can imagine.

Even centuries beyond their deaths, there are some whose influence perseveres and gives them a kind of immortality, for good or bad.  Will you and everyone else be dust in "billions of years?" Of course, but there is so much possible happiness, goodness and fulfillment in your lifetime and the lifetimes of your loved ones, that the distant future has no significance.

Enjoy your life and do your best to pass that on to others.  Cheers.

 
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Cavebear on November 11, 2016, 01:04:25 AM
Quote from: Iusedtobelievein on November 10, 2016, 07:09:09 PM
that soon we will all be nothing more than a rotting piece of flesh in a coffin?  Big change in belief.  I am having a hard time grasping the possibility that we will all be a rotting piece of meat in a coffin, nothing more, no afterlife for the people and animals I love (loved)...that I will one day no longer see the people and animals  I love (loved).  Mainly the God I believed in with all my heart and soul--or what I thought was a soul--is just magical thinking of the human brain.  How do I handle this...?...that we all are just a wink in a moment of time.  That you, me, them will one day be nothing more than a name...just a name in a census record...just a name.  And this will happen soon especially if one considers, really considers, that the earth is literally Billions of years...Billions of years old.  Billions.  And billions of humans have walked this earth...nothing special about you, about me, about the people I love (loved) including the children I have loved.That we are no more when we die...just creatures who die with nothing immortal about our souls...that souls don't exist.  So how does one go from believing in this to all this? Btw,  I have had too much wine to drink.  Because...because the thought that the mother I loved, that the animals I loved, end at the grave.  It's too much for this primitive animal brain to handle.

Help me please to handle this possibility sez the secular nun.  Big change...oh, yeah.

Smash a housefly with a swatter.  It is dead.  We all will be equally dead some day. 
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Baruch on November 11, 2016, 08:14:42 AM
You are safe.  It takes a really big flyswatter to smash a bear ;-)
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Gawdzilla Sama on November 11, 2016, 08:20:27 AM
Quote from: Iusedtobelievein on November 10, 2016, 07:09:09 PM
that soon we will all be nothing more than a rotting piece of flesh in a coffin?  Big change in belief.  I am having a hard time grasping the possibility that we will all be a rotting piece of meat in a coffin, nothing more, no afterlife for the people and animals I love (loved)...that I will one day no longer see the people and animals  I love (loved).  Mainly the God I believed in with all my heart and soul--or what I thought was a soul--is just magical thinking of the human brain.  How do I handle this...?...that we all are just a wink in a moment of time.  That you, me, them will one day be nothing more than a name...just a name in a census record...just a name.  And this will happen soon especially if one considers, really considers, that the earth is literally Billions of years...Billions of years old.  Billions.  And billions of humans have walked this earth...nothing special about you, about me, about the people I love (loved) including the children I have loved.That we are no more when we die...just creatures who die with nothing immortal about our souls...that souls don't exist.  So how does one go from believing in this to all this? Btw,  I have had too much wine to drink.  Because...because the thought that the mother I loved, that the animals I loved, end at the grave.  It's too much for this primitive animal brain to handle.

Help me please to handle this possibility sez the secular nun.  Big change...oh, yeah.
Can't help, I've been rational all my life. (Except for the time I volunteered for a job that would probably get me killed, but that was military, not religious.)

I can say that it's easy to live without expectation of an afterlife, as easy as living without the "sure and certain hope" that Santa will be here in a few weeks.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Cavebear on November 11, 2016, 08:26:04 AM
Quote from: Gawdzilla Sama on November 11, 2016, 08:20:27 AM
Can't help, I've been rational all my life. (Except for the time I volunteered for a job that would probably get me killed, but that was military, not religious.)

I can say that it's easy to live without expectation of an afterlife, as easy as living without the "sure and certain hope" that Santa will be here in a few weeks.

Agreeing with you on this.  Once you catch on to the fact that there is no "afterlife", this one becomes more valuable. It the only one we get.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: widdershins on November 11, 2016, 10:11:14 AM
A part of growing up is coming to terms with one's own morality.  That usually happens over time as we mature, making it not so bad.  But if you've avoided it all your life with magical thinking then coming to grips with it all at once can be quite difficult, I'm sure.  Reality is as it is.  There's nothing we can do to change it.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Cavebear on November 11, 2016, 10:17:31 AM
Quote from: widdershins on November 11, 2016, 10:11:14 AM
A part of growing up is coming to terms with one's own morality.  That usually happens over time as we mature, making it not so bad.  But if you've avoided it all your life with magical thinking then coming to grips with it all at once can be quite difficult, I'm sure.  Reality is as it is.  There's nothing we can do to change it.

Morality is religious and externally applied.  Ethics are personal and individual.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Baruch on November 11, 2016, 12:11:17 PM
Quote from: widdershins on November 11, 2016, 10:11:14 AM
A part of growing up is coming to terms with one's own morality.  That usually happens over time as we mature, making it not so bad.  But if you've avoided it all your life with magical thinking then coming to grips with it all at once can be quite difficult, I'm sure.  Reality is as it is.  There's nothing we can do to change it.

That is called Fatalism.  Like Cheney, I make my own reality!
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Solomon Zorn on November 11, 2016, 04:23:47 PM
Quotethat soon we will all be nothing more than a rotting piece of flesh in a coffin?  Big change in belief.  I am having a hard time grasping the possibility that we will all be a rotting piece of meat in a coffin, nothing more, no afterlife for the people and animals I love (loved)...that I will one day no longer see the people and animals  I love (loved).  Mainly the God I believed in with all my heart and soul--or what I thought was a soul--is just magical thinking of the human brain.  How do I handle this...?...that we all are just a wink in a moment of time.  That you, me, them will one day be nothing more than a name...just a name in a census record...just a name.  And this will happen soon especially if one considers, really considers, that the earth is literally Billions of years...Billions of years old.  Billions.  And billions of humans have walked this earth...nothing special about you, about me, about the people I love (loved) including the children I have loved.That we are no more when we die...just creatures who die with nothing immortal about our souls...that souls don't exist.  So how does one go from believing in this to all this? Btw,  I have had too much wine to drink.  Because...because the thought that the mother I loved, that the animals I loved, end at the grave.  It's too much for this primitive animal brain to handle.

Help me please to handle this possibility sez the secular nun.  Big change...oh, yeah.
I can't tell you what to live for, but find some good reason in yourself, man. Life is fleeting and the good stuff doesn't last forever. For everything that lives there is a beginning, and an end. Ashes to ashes, dust to dust. If there is something beyond the grave, in store for us, it will take care of itself. There is nothing I can do to prove it, disprove it, prevent it, nor prepare for it. No one knows. Those who say they know are deluded. Just let it go, is my advice.

As for passed loved ones, they are alive in the past. That's how I see it. A portion of their pattern is resurrected when I remember them. So I try to remember them fondly.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Simon Moon on November 16, 2016, 07:49:54 PM
Quote from: Iusedtobelievein on November 10, 2016, 07:09:09 PM
that soon we will all be nothing more than a rotting piece of flesh in a coffin?  Big change in belief.  I am having a hard time grasping the possibility that we will all be a rotting piece of meat in a coffin, nothing more, no afterlife for the people and animals I love (loved)...that I will one day no longer see the people and animals  I love (loved).  Mainly the God I believed in with all my heart and soul--or what I thought was a soul--is just magical thinking of the human brain.  How do I handle this...?...that we all are just a wink in a moment of time.  That you, me, them will one day be nothing more than a name...just a name in a census record...just a name.  And this will happen soon especially if one considers, really considers, that the earth is literally Billions of years...Billions of years old.  Billions.  And billions of humans have walked this earth...nothing special about you, about me, about the people I love (loved) including the children I have loved.That we are no more when we die...just creatures who die with nothing immortal about our souls...that souls don't exist.  So how does one go from believing in this to all this? Btw,  I have had too much wine to drink.  Because...because the thought that the mother I loved, that the animals I loved, end at the grave.  It's too much for this primitive animal brain to handle.

Help me please to handle this possibility sez the secular nun.  Big change...oh, yeah.


You have to start caring whether your beliefs are true, or likely true, more than wanting to have beliefs that make you feel good.

Do you want to have an internal map of reality that is as close to reality as possible? Or do you want to live with a 'fantasy' map of reality?

The best method to attain the above, is by basing your beliefs on demonstrable and falsifiable evidence, and valid and sound logic.

You will live on in the memories of the people you affect, and the people they affect.

Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Cavebear on November 17, 2016, 05:58:10 AM
Quote from: Simon Moon on November 16, 2016, 07:49:54 PM

You have to start caring whether your beliefs are true, or likely true, more than wanting to have beliefs that make you feel good.

Do you want to have an internal map of reality that is as close to reality as possible? Or do you want to live with a 'fantasy' map of reality?

The best method to attain the above, is by basing your beliefs on demonstrable and falsifiable evidence, and valid and sound logic.

You will live on in the memories of the people you affect, and the people they affect.

I prefer a reality map.  It has worked well my adult life of 55+ years. 
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Unbeliever on November 17, 2016, 06:41:20 PM
Hell, even when I did believe it was more of a working hypothesis than faith. I had no trouble tossing the idea of eternal life as soon as I realized I need no longer fear that eternity spent in agony in hell.


(https://s3.amazonaws.com/lowres.cartoonstock.com/death-death-die-dies-afterlife-hell-tcrn693_low.jpg)
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Baruch on November 17, 2016, 07:02:46 PM
Hell is a frigid place where cowardly Vikings go.  They are stuck with Swedish women instead of Valkyries ;-)

Belief in eternity as ... a really long time .. is metaphysical ignorance.  Fear of death is human, but to give into that fear ... means you are a cowardly Viking.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Gawdzilla Sama on November 18, 2016, 11:35:01 AM
Quote from: Cavebear on November 11, 2016, 08:26:04 AM
Agreeing with you on this.  Once you catch on to the fact that there is no "afterlife", this one becomes more valuable. It the only one we get.
Unless you're Gojira, in which case you will sequel for all eternity.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Cavebear on November 22, 2016, 12:09:02 AM
Quote from: Gawdzilla Sama on November 18, 2016, 11:35:01 AM
Unless you're Gojira, in which case you will sequel for all eternity.

I assume that is some anime joke?
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Baruch on November 22, 2016, 06:58:25 AM
Quote from: Cavebear on November 22, 2016, 12:09:02 AM
I assume that is some anime joke?

Some of our posters ... are anime jokes ;-)
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Cavebear on December 02, 2016, 11:04:46 AM
Looked up "Gojira".  Japanese for Godzilla.  Or to be more correct, I suppose, "Godzilla" is American for Gojira.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Baruch on December 02, 2016, 01:07:50 PM
Quote from: Cavebear on December 02, 2016, 11:04:46 AM
Looked up "Gojira".  Japanese for Godzilla.  Or to be more correct, I suppose, "Godzilla" is American for Gojira.

You are not ready to leave the Zen temple yet, Bruin ;-)
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Hijiri Byakuren on December 02, 2016, 05:01:36 PM
Quote from: Cavebear on December 02, 2016, 11:04:46 AM
Looked up "Gojira".  Japanese for Godzilla.  Or to be more correct, I suppose, "Godzilla" is American for Gojira.
Actually, they're both mispronunciations of ã,´ã,¸ãƒ©. "Go-ji-ra" and "Go-dzi-la" are both acceptable romanizations, and "Godzilla" was the one chosen by his Japanese creators.

There really isn't a correct way to romanize Japanese; only less-incorrect ways.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Cavebear on December 09, 2016, 02:04:20 AM
Quote from: Hijiri Byakuren on December 02, 2016, 05:01:36 PM
Actually, they're both mispronunciations of ã,´ã,¸ãƒ©. "Go-ji-ra" and "Go-dzi-la" are both acceptable romanizations, and "Godzilla" was the one chosen by his Japanese creators.

There really isn't a correct way to romanize Japanese; only less-incorrect ways.

IIRC, linguistic theory says there are about 40 sounds and most languages use about 25.  Human palates form at a very young age, which is why becoming TRULY fluent in non-birth languages is very difficult or nearly impossible.

The understanding of that is one reason the names of foreign cities keep changing in foreign languages. 

And BTW, the Japanese never called the creature "Go-ji-ra".  "R" isn't one of their consonants.
Title: Re: So, how does one go from believing in the eternity of the spirit to considering
Post by: Baruch on December 09, 2016, 07:07:25 AM
http://vocaloid.wikia.com/wiki/Japanese_Phonetics  ... see third from bottom in chart ... it is "La etc that they can't pronounce" ;-)

http://vocaloid.wikia.com/wiki/Hatsune_Miku ... even simulated Japanese pop stars say it like their creators do ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=egcfC7PCneQ

There are modern versions of mythology, people even go to live concerts to watch holograms.